STEM or Non-STEM in US? Where Should You Head!

You may be an aspirant to study in the US but confused about choosing a major, especially the decision-making process regarding STEM vs. non-STEM. This article will help you make this clearer for you a better decision.

Before going into comparison, it’s essential to define what STEM and non-STEM courses mean, what their fields are, and how they work.

What Are STEM and Non-STEM Courses?

STEM courses are those that focus on the core disciplines of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. These courses provide in-depth technical knowledge and often involve hands-on experimentation, data analysis, and problem-solving. The goal is to equip students with the skills necessary to innovate and excel in highly technical fields. Typical subjects include:

• Computer Science
• Biotechnology
• Engineering (Civil, Mechanical, Electrical, etc.)
• Mathematics
• Physics
• Chemistry

These fields are critical to the future of industries such as healthcare, aerospace, environmental sustainability, and IT. A STEM education aims not only to teach specific facts but also to develop critical thinking and problem-solving abilities.

On the other hand, non-STEM courses include a wide range of disciplines that do not directly fall under science, technology, engineering, or mathematics. These subjects often focus on building skills such as communication, critical thinking, creativity, and cultural awareness. Non-STEM disciplines include:

• Business Management
• Marketing
• Law
• Journalism
• Social Sciences
• Humanities (Literature, History, Philosophy)
• Arts (Fine Arts, Design, Music)

Non-STEM education nurtures the softer skills that are essential for leadership, communication, and understanding human behavior, and it prepares individuals for roles in fields that require a deep understanding of people and society.

Check Out:  Should International Students Choose a Masters or PhD in the US?

STEM vs. Non-STEM: Key Differences

While STEM and non-STEM courses might seem distinct, both types of education provide essential skills and knowledge. However, their focus, teaching methods, and outcomes differ significantly. Let's break down the key differences:

1. Teaching Approach

Traditional Education (Non-STEM)

• Non-STEM education tends to emphasize knowledge retention and theoretical understanding. Students are often required to memorize facts, dates, and concepts, and exams typically test recall.
• In traditional education, subjects are often taught separately. History, literature, and political science are seen as distinct, isolated areas of knowledge.
• Traditional education is often lecture-heavy, with teachers delivering content to students in a one-way format.

STEM Education

• STEM education breaks down the barriers between subjects by integrating them. For example, a lesson in physics might involve mathematical formulas and technological applications. Students engage with real-world problems and are encouraged to think critically about how these problems can be solved using the knowledge they’ve acquired.
• STEM emphasizes applying concepts rather than rote memorization. Students are asked to solve practical problems, conduct experiments, and innovate using their knowledge.
• STEM education often involves group projects and collaborative activities where students can learn from one another and solve problems together.

2. Career Prospects

STEM Careers

• STEM graduates generally command higher salaries compared to their non-STEM counterparts. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, STEM occupations had a median annual wage 48% higher than that of all other occupations.
• The demand for STEM professionals continues to rise. Fields like software development, cybersecurity, healthcare, and engineering have numerous opportunities, and many of these jobs are in industries that are at the forefront of innovation.
• STEM professionals are often more mobile and have access to jobs globally due to the universal demand for technical expertise.

Non-STEM Careers

• Non-STEM graduates may pursue careers in sectors such as business, law, journalism, education, arts, and government. These roles require critical thinking, communication, creativity, and leadership skills.
• A non-STEM degree, especially in fields like business, marketing, or social sciences, provides a broad set of skills that are transferable across a wide range of industries.
• Non-STEM fields allow individuals to work in roles that directly impact society, such as education, law, public policy, and social services.

See also: USA vs Canada: Which One Is Better For You?

Pros of STEM Education

STEM education is often praised for preparing students for the future, especially in a rapidly changing job market. Here are some key advantages:

1. Critical Life Skills

STEM education goes beyond teaching facts. It helps students develop essential life skills such as:

• Problem-solving: STEM students are constantly faced with complex problems that require innovative solutions. This teaches them how to approach challenges systematically and creatively.
• Collaboration: STEM projects often require teamwork, teaching students how to work effectively with others and appreciate diverse perspectives.
• Resilience (GRIT): STEM encourages perseverance. When students fail, they’re taught to try again, learn from their mistakes, and keep improving.

2. Career Opportunities

STEM graduates are highly sought after in the job market. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projects that STEM jobs will grow by 10.5% from 2020 to 2030, faster than the average for all occupations. This growth is driven by demand in fields like computer science, healthcare, and renewable energy. The demand for STEM professionals is expected to grow significantly in the coming years, especially in fields like artificial intelligence, biotechnology, and data science. Some specific benefits include:

• Higher salaries: According to a report by Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce, STEM graduates earn, on average, $24,000 more per year than non-STEM graduates. For example, the median salary for a software developer is around $110,140, compared to the national median salary of $41,950 for all occupations.
• Global opportunities: STEM professionals have the advantage of being able to work internationally, as the skills they acquire are in demand across borders.
• Diverse fields to choose from: STEM offers a broad range of career paths. Whether you’re interested in working in healthcare, technology, engineering, or research, a STEM education can open doors to a wide array of professions.

3. Promoting Gender Equality and Diversity

Another significant benefit of STEM education is its potential to break down gender barriers and promote equality:

• Encouraging diversity in technical fields: STEM programs help expose students of all genders and backgrounds to fields that have traditionally been male-dominated, such as engineering and computer science. According to the National Science Foundation (NSF), women currently make up only 28% of the STEM workforce in the U.S., despite constituting nearly 50% of the overall workforce. However, initiatives designed to encourage women and underrepresented minorities to pursue STEM have been gaining traction in recent years.
• Empowering women in STEM: Initiatives aimed at supporting women in STEM have gained momentum in recent years, creating an environment where women are encouraged to pursue careers in science and technology.

4. Innovation and Creativity

STEM education fosters a culture of innovation. Students are encouraged to think outside the box, experiment, and create. This is especially valuable in fields like technology and engineering, where new ideas lead to the development of groundbreaking products and solutions. In the U.S., the technology sector alone contributed $1.8 trillion to the economy in 2020, representing 9.2% of the nation’s GDP, according to the Consumer Technology Association (CTA).

5. Societal Impact

STEM education equips individuals with the tools to solve pressing global challenges. From climate change and health issues to cybersecurity threats and infrastructure problems, STEM professionals play a crucial role in addressing the most urgent issues of our time.

Check Out: Private or Public Universities in US: What’s Best for You?

Cons of STEM Education

While STEM education offers numerous advantages, it’s not without its challenges. Here are some potential drawbacks:

1. High Initial Costs

One of the most significant barriers to implementing STEM programs is the initial investment. Building a STEM curriculum requires funding for equipment, materials, and teacher training. Many schools struggle to meet these financial demands, especially in underfunded regions.

2. Teacher Training

Not all educators are trained in STEM subjects. For effective STEM education, teachers need to have a strong background in the sciences and technology, along with the ability to integrate these subjects in a cross-disciplinary manner. Professional development programs are essential, but they take time and resources to implement. According to a U.S. Department of Education report, nearly half of all U.S. schools report a shortage of qualified STEM teachers, particularly in mathematics and science.

3. Pressure and Stress

The demanding nature of STEM education can sometimes create pressure for students. The focus on problem-solving and experimentation can lead to high levels of stress, especially if students feel they are not succeeding or have difficulty grasping complex concepts. For some students, this can lead to frustration and burnout.

A study by The Journal of Educational Psychology found that students in STEM programs report higher levels of stress and anxiety compared to their peers in non-STEM fields.

4. Not a Universal Fit

STEM education isn’t the right fit for everyone. Some students may excel in non-technical subjects and may feel alienated in a STEM-focused environment. The pressure to conform to the "STEM or bust" mindset can discourage students from pursuing careers that may be more aligned with their interests and abilities.

Pros of Non-STEM Education

Non-STEM education plays a crucial role in producing well-rounded individuals capable of contributing to society in many different ways. Here are the key advantages:

1. Development of Soft Skills

Non-STEM education emphasizes critical thinking, communication, and creativity. These skills are essential in fields such as business, law, social services, and the arts. Strong communication skills, both written and verbal, are highly valued in the professional world. For example, jobs in business and finance are expected to grow by 5.7% by 2029, with the demand for financial analysts and marketing specialists continuing to rise.

2. Broad Career Opportunities

While STEM fields are crucial for technological advancement, non-STEM careers are equally diverse. Graduates with a degree in business, law, or social sciences can work in a wide array of industries, including management, education, healthcare, and media. Non-STEM graduates are also equipped with transferable skills that are valued across professions.

3. Focus on Human Development

Non-STEM education often focuses on understanding human behavior, culture, and society. This is especially valuable in fields like psychology, sociology, education, and the arts. Graduates in these fields contribute to improving human well-being and society at large. Social workers in the U.S. make an average annual salary of $51,760, and their work is critical in supporting underserved communities.

4. Creativity and Innovation

Non-STEM disciplines, particularly the arts, encourage creativity and artistic expression. Whether through literature, music, or design, Non-STEM education fosters an environment where students are encouraged to innovate, think outside the box, and express their ideas in unique ways. 

Creative industries contributed $2.3 trillion to the global economy in 2020, representing 3% of global GDP.

Cons of Non-STEM Education

While Non-STEM education offers numerous benefits, it’s not without its disadvantages:

1. Job Market Saturation

Over 40% of college graduates with degrees in humanities, arts, or social sciences are underemployed or working in jobs that don't require a degree. Some non-STEM fields, such as humanities or journalism, are facing challenges in terms of job availability. In certain areas, there is increased competition for jobs, and graduates may face difficulty finding employment in their desired fields.

2. Lower Earning Potential

On average, non-STEM careers tend to have lower starting salaries compared to STEM roles. While some non-STEM jobs can offer lucrative opportunities, especially in business or law, many others, such as those in the arts, may not provide the same financial rewards. The median annual salary for a graduate with a degree in humanities is around $45,000, compared to $61,000 for those with degrees in STEM fields. Over a lifetime, this gap can result in a significant difference in earnings.

3. Limited Technical Skills

Non-STEM education may not provide the same level of technical expertise and digital literacy as STEM fields. In a world increasingly reliant on technology, students who don’t gain technical skills may find it challenging to compete in the job market.

Take a look: Your Guide to ESL vs. Main Courses for International Students

Best U.S. Universities for STEM

1. MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
   MIT is widely considered the best for STEM, especially in computer science, engineering, and physics. Known for its groundbreaking research and innovative spirit, MIT offers a hands-on learning environment that encourages students to solve real-world problems. Its competitive acceptance rate of 6.7% reflects its exclusivity.
2. Stanford University
   Located in Silicon Valley, Stanford is a hub for tech, AI, and engineering. Its proximity to major tech companies provides unmatched internship and networking opportunities. With an acceptance rate of 4.3%, Stanford is a top choice for students aiming to lead in the tech world.
3. Caltech (California Institute of Technology)
   Caltech is a small but powerful institution with a focus on deep scientific inquiry, particularly in physics, chemistry, and engineering. With a low student-to-faculty ratio, students receive direct mentorship from leading researchers. Its 6.4% acceptance rate speaks to its selectivity.
4. Harvard University
   Harvard, though known for its humanities, also excels in STEM, especially life sciences and computer science. Its interdisciplinary approach fosters collaboration across various fields, making it a great choice for students interested in research. The acceptance rate is 4.6%.
5. UC Berkeley (University of California, Berkeley)
   Berkeley is a top choice for students pursuing engineering, computer science, and environmental science. It’s known for its strong research programs and proximity to Silicon Valley. The acceptance rate is 14.8%, and students have ample opportunities for collaboration and innovation.

Best U.S. Universities for Non-STEM

1. Harvard University
   Harvard offers top-tier programs in law, political science, economics, and history, making it a prime destination for students interested in business, law, or public service. Its global network and academic rigor set it apart, with an acceptance rate of 4.6%.
2. Princeton University
   Princeton is renowned for its social sciences, including political science, economics, and philosophy. The university’s small class sizes and strong faculty mentorship provide a personalized education, with an acceptance rate of 5.6%.
3. Yale University
   Yale is an excellent choice for students pursuing law, journalism, or humanities. Its critical thinking focus and commitment to societal issues make it a top destination for future leaders in public service. Yale's acceptance rate is 6.3%.
4. Columbia University
   Located in New York City, Columbia offers strong programs in law, business, journalism, and the arts. The city’s vast opportunities in media and finance complement the university’s academic programs, and its acceptance rate is 3.9%.
5. University of Chicago
   UChicago stands out for its economics, law, and social sciences programs. Known for intellectual rigor and interdisciplinary study, UChicago is a great fit for students aiming for careers in public policy, economics, or law. The acceptance rate is 6.2%.

FAQs 

1. How can STEM education benefit non-STEM students?

STEM education, even for non-STEM students, can offer benefits such as improved problem-solving abilities, critical thinking, and the ability to approach complex issues with a technical mindset. These skills can be valuable in non-STEM careers like business, law, and education, where analytical thinking and data-driven decision-making are increasingly important.

2. How does STEM education influence gender diversity in fields like engineering and technology?

STEM education plays a significant role in promoting gender diversity by offering inclusive learning environments and encouraging equal opportunities for both male and female students. By exposing students to these fields early on, STEM programs have been instrumental in narrowing the gender gap in traditionally male-dominated industries such as engineering and technology.

3. Are STEM graduates more likely to transition into non-STEM careers later in life?

Yes, many STEM graduates transition into non-STEM careers over time. For instance, individuals with a STEM background often pursue careers in business, finance, or even entrepreneurship, where they can leverage their problem-solving skills and technical expertise. The adaptability of STEM education allows graduates to shift fields with a strong foundation in data analysis, strategy, and innovation.

4. Can Non-STEM education provide as many global opportunities as STEM education?

While STEM education opens doors to highly technical, global opportunities, non-STEM education also offers vast international prospects. Careers in law, politics, journalism, and business can be globally impactful, and universities around the world value graduates with strong communication skills, cultural understanding, and leadership—qualities emphasized in non-STEM disciplines.

5. What role do non-STEM universities play in the innovation of society?

Though often associated with technical fields, non-STEM universities contribute significantly to innovation by developing ideas in areas like social justice, policy reform, media, and cultural studies. These fields drive societal progress through critical discourse, advocacy, and creative solutions to global challenges, complementing the work of STEM professionals.

6. Can STEM programs become more inclusive for students with non-technical backgrounds?

Yes, STEM programs are increasingly designed to be inclusive of students with non-technical backgrounds. Many universities offer bridging programs or introductory courses in subjects like coding, engineering fundamentals, and data science, allowing students from diverse academic backgrounds to transition into STEM fields with the right support.

7. How does studying both STEM and non-STEM subjects benefit students?

A combined approach to STEM and non-STEM education allows students to develop a balanced skill set. While STEM provides technical expertise, non-STEM subjects teach creativity, human understanding, and effective communication. This combination fosters well-rounded individuals who can approach problems from multiple angles, making them highly adaptable in any profession.

8. How can non-STEM graduates leverage STEM skills in their careers?

Non-STEM graduates can leverage STEM skills such as data analysis, technical writing, and problem-solving in various careers. For example, a graduate in business can use data-driven decision-making to improve company performance, or a marketing professional can apply technology tools to analyze consumer behavior and market trends.

9. Are there any emerging non-STEM careers that are in high demand?

Yes, fields like digital marketing, user experience (UX) design, and public relations are rapidly growing. These industries blend creativity with technology, offering opportunities for non-STEM graduates to work in innovative, high-demand fields. Additionally, sustainability careers, including those in environmental law and sustainable business practices, are seeing increased demand globally.

10. How do universities support students who are undecided between STEM and non-STEM fields?

Many universities offer interdisciplinary programs and exploratory tracks that allow undecided students to sample both STEM and non-STEM courses before committing to a specific major. Students can often take foundational courses in math, science, and humanities, giving them the flexibility to determine which field suits their interests and skills best.